Project Haruhi
20Jul/1018

The Four Laws of Moe

Is this moe's true form?

This is a refined and expanded version of an editorial I originally wrote for Japanator. The original can be found here.

It seems one of the biggest problems in the ongoing moe debate is the lack of any concrete definition for the term "moe." This has lead to all sorts of argument among otaku; some believe the term can be applied to any female character the viewer considers cute, while others argue it should be strictly limited to its original Japanese definition. Personally, I think the truth lies in between these two extremes. After all, language is defined by its usage, not by the opinions of a few crazed fanboys or some dusty old dictionary. Therefore, based on my own observations and research, I have created the Four Laws of Moe. I believe these laws lay out, in clear and concise detail, the exact parameters of moe and what traits a character must exhibit in order to be considered as such. Of course, these laws are merely a reflection of my own opinion; feel free to improve upon them, argue against them or even construct your own alternative theory. Whatever the case, I'd love to hear your thoughts in the comment section below.

Read more after the break!

Moe moe kyun!

The initial definition of the word "moe" is far different from the one we use today. Originally, it referred to an interest in a particular kind of character; for example, a catgirl fetish would be "nekomimi-moe," a glasses fetish would be "meganekko-moe," and so on. Over time, the term evolved to describe any anime or manga character that elicited feelings of protectiveness in male viewers. Unfortunately, that definition is far too broad to be practical. Therefore, based on common archetypes present in the recent 'moe boom', as well as popular usage of the term in the anime fandom, I've compiled the following Four Laws of Moe. These laws explain what I believe to be the defining aspects of any moe character.

First Law: Moe characters are cute.

The concept of 'cuteness' is very important in Japanese pop culture, and moe exemplifies this. A moe character will always be as cute as possible, even at the expense of being sexually attractive. In fact, a moe character will not be outright sultry or seductive, as this takes away form their innocence (explored further in the Third Law). This is because many men find sexually confident women (including those in real life) to be intimidating or manipulative, and thus not ideal for fantasizing.

In order to facilitate maximum cuteness, moe characters will almost always be female and adhere to laws two through four. Naturally, such cute charm lends to their merchandising potential; hardcore otaku are always ready to buy figures and posters of their waifu. These merchandising sales, in turn, subsidize futher late-night anime production, and thus create more moe-type shows. This is the so-called 'vicious moe cycle' that some anime fans feel has lead to the downfall of the medium.

Second Law: Moe characters are young.

Generally, moe girls will be around junior or high-school age, the time when they are just starting to explore their sexual identity but still retain childlike innocence. This youth allows moe characters to be fetishized without making the viewer feel uncomfortable about lolicon, but still preserves the cute naivete (not to mention virginity) that creates feelings of protectiveness. These feelings are often linked to a fatherly instinct, especially among male otaku in their twenties and thirties. Incidentally, this demographic also has a great deal of liquid capital to spend on the aforementioned merchandise.

This is not to say older characters cannot be moe. As long as they are young at heart (like Mutsumi Otohime from Love Hina) and adhere to the other three laws, they still qualify.

Third Law: Moe characters are innocent.

This goes hand-in-hand with the second law. Moe girls are almost always virgins, and frequently have had no romantic experiences whatsoever. They often have a cheerfully optimistic view of reality, and are completely unaware of the feelings and/or perversions of those around them. In their first romantic encounters, they are usually extremely shy and tend to blush a lot. This makes them seem both physically and emotionally vulnerable, once again adding to the cuteness factor and creating feelings of protectiveness.

This is probably the most important law. Without innocence, it's hard to have a character retain the sense of vulnerability that defines moe. In fact, 2chan's infamous 'virgin hunters' value this trait above all else... even going so far as to throw temper tantrums when they discover their waifu isn't as uncorrupted as they had thought (NSFW).

Fourth Law: Moe characters are quirky.

Moe characters usually have some sort of quirk that makes them stand out from the crowd. This can be a unique physical feature (i.e. lolfang, glasses or twintails) or an unusual way of speaking (i.e. ending sentences with desu or nyoro~n). Another common quirk is behavioral in nature; common examples include the lazy girl who is always late for class, the clumsy girl who can't do anything right, or the tsundere girl who inflicts pain on those she loves. The best kind of quirk adds to the overall cute factor of the moe character in question, without being socially undesirable. For example, running to school with toast hanging out of your mouth is fine... but collecting porn magazines is not.

Of course, many of these so-called quirks have become so common that they are now tired cliches; thighhigh stockings, glasses and twintails are three particularly egregious examples. Despite this, they have become synonymous with the moe aesthetic, thus leading to their continued popularity.

As a test, let's apply these laws to a few examples from an old favorite of mine, The Melancholy of Haruhi Suzumiya. Any character that gets a score of 3 or higher is considered moe.

Kyon (not female, but bear with me)

Cute: NO
Young: YES
Innocent: NO
Quirky: Uh... kinda?
Score: 1.5/4
Verdict: NOT MOE

Haruhi Suzumiya

Cute: YES
Young: YES
Innocent: Uh... kinda?
Quirky: YES
Score: 3.5/4
Verdict: MOE

Yuki Nagato

Cute: YES
Young: YES
Innocent: NO
Quirky: YES
Score: 3/4
Verdict: MOE

Mikuru Asahina

Cute: YES
Young: YES
Innocent: YES
Quirky: YES
Score: 4/4
Verdict: MAXIMUM MOE!!

And that's my proposed system for determining moe. But how does this apply the medium of anime as a whole?

In my opinion, moe is a kind of highly specialized fanservice; it creates characters that are (to otaku) highly desirable, in both personality and sex appeal, without any of the perceived drawbacks real women have. That said, it is subject to all the limitations of regular fanservice. When moe is used sparingly, as merely one aspect of a character's personality, it can effectively complement their other traits and make them more well-rounded. However, when a character is defined entirely by moe, with no other redeeming aspects whatsoever, they becomes two-dimensonal and uninteresting. In otaku parlance, such characters are called moeblobs, since their personalities are so ill-defined that they are little more than useless blobs. Like the big-breasted nurse from Highschool of the Dead, who exists solely to titillate viewers, moeblobs are often relegated to menial fanservice roles. Mikuru Asahina is, in my opinion, an excellent example; she was the only female character in Haruhi that had no dignity, usefulness or interesting character development besides being Haruhi's sexual plaything. This made her a flat and boring character, and an excellent example of too much moe.

Cute but totally useless.

Well, those are my thoughts on moe. I'd love to hear yours in the comments below!

Further reading:

About Jon

Jon is a Japanese culture enthusiast, professional pervert and roleplaying fanatic who appreciates flexible gender identities. He enjoys science fiction, Gunpla, classical music and Red Stripe.
  • AZNFireBurn

    Brilliant 😀
    Unfortunately I also enjoy the moeblobs :3

    • To each his own.

      I suppose I shouldn’t be too critical of moeblobs, since I like K-ON!.
      ^_^;

  • This is pretty much how I percieved Moe to be, the whole protective “fatherly” emotion that derives from the character to the audience. Although I never find any fetishisation or sexual desire from Moe, neither does anyone I know. It’s like a big bro-little sis kinda deal; the only thing you wanna do is give em a big, friendly, Christian Side Hug ^_^

    As for Mikiru Asahina she started to get REAL annoying towards the end leading to a Moe Overdose and finally: Moe Comatose. . . or was that just me?

  • It’s definitely possible to enjoy moe without the sexual aspect. For example, K-ON! is pretty much devoid of lewd fanservice of any kind, and many otaku enjoy it without fetishizing the girls. At the same time, products like the official Mio bikini figure indicate that those kind of sexually-minded otaku do exist, and are a driving force behind the anime merchandise market.

  • How should I say this… I’m not really in the comment but:

    First of all, I’d rather stick with paragraph 2’s definition because I find it more practical to use and a less creepy definition. And what’s more, the otaku culture has cultured and shaped the term moe into a more “fuzzy” form where one person can simply call anything moe as long as it falls in these categories: 1) the subject is female 2) she’s cute and young and 3) SHE’s awesome which more or less the same as your 4 categories (though for me, I believe innocence already falls under cuteness). The real definition was lost along the way as more people popularized the term which is quite stupid but that’s culture for you. Again, I am trying to stick with the real “term” as much as possible. 😀

    P.S. Sorry if this comment was a load of crap… Ihasworktodo. :3

    • And yet, the popular usage of the term has changed. Language is constantly evolving, and the meaning of words is always in flux. For example, “gay” used to mean “happy and jovial,” but hardly anybody uses it in that context anymore. The definition of “moe” has similarly changed. That’s not to say the original definition is invalid… but you can’t ignore the word’s more contemporary meaning.

      • I am not against change or anything and I do accept that moe was popularized as a fuzzy term that we, both of us, mentioned above in our own opinions. What I’m really trying to state is that for me, I find it more fitting to use the less “creepy” and more original definition of moe. ;3c

        and btw, cute orignally meant ugly but presentable. SOIAMPROUDTOSAYIAMNOTCUTE.

  • Hmm… this whole debate over the meaning of moe reminds me of a Lucky Channel episode.

  • I know where tsundere came from..,. it was in a game. LOL. yes, most otaku terms evolve in this way. IAMFOLLOWINGTHESEBASTIANWAY. >///<

  • I prefer my moe devoid of any sexual aspect; i’m not prudish or anything it just makes uncomfortable watching when there is constant unnecessary fetishisation or “sexing up” of high school girls (as if it is ever really necessary). It’s kinda like the uneasy feeling when you watch a risque scene in a movie or game (i’m talking to YOU Mass Effect) with your parents present =/

    And as you said, K-ON is Moe yet something your grandma would approve of XD Also, I don’t collect the figurine stuff but from what i’ve scene 97% of it is sexed up somewhat =/

    Actually, reading this back might make me sound a bit prudish but oh well. . . I guess I am ^^

  • I was actually just thinking about that.
    But i feel like now Tsundere has a far more defined definition then it did at that point. correct me if I’m wrong but a Tsundere is a (usually female, but can be male) character that has a tough exterior and who’s usual gut reaction is violent, but deep down is a kind-hearted, needy character.
    (ex. Kagami from Lucky Star, Okazaki from Clannad, Taiga from Toradora.)

    Wait, is K-On!s Mio, Tsundere? I never noticed.

    Overall, great article, I enjoyed it!

    • I considered Mio to be Tsundere; at least a little. (don’t forget Kyou from Clannad 😉 )

  • J

    verdict on me…
    cute: yes
    innocent: uh… maybe
    quirky: at times
    young: yes
    3/4
    Moe: yes

  • Great job! I think anyone who’s just getting into anime should read this article as a “starter guide” of sorts. It could help prevent a lot of the confusions and misconceptions (and criticisms) there are about moe.

    I shall bookmark this article, and will likely use it for reference whenever someone asks me what the hell moe is.

  • Me

    cute: I’d like to think so
    Innocent: I’d like to think I was innocent enough.
    Quirky: I hope so
    Young: enough
    ?/4

    hmm

  • You:
    Cute: HELL NO
    Innocent: I’ve seen your porn collection.
    Quirky: Not exceptionally.
    Young: Not young enough
    0/4

    Verdict: ANTI-MOE

  • ME
    Cute: Er… I guess?
    Innocent: Not even close.
    Quirky: At times, I guess.
    Young: Actually I’m probably TOO young.
    2.5/4

    Verdict: ALMOST MOE BUT NOT QUITE

  • VXLbeast

    Like. 🙂

  • Pingback: Rubénerd : links for 2010-07-23()

  • Pingback: Deconstructing K-ON! – The Takotsuboya Doujin Trilogy « Project Haruhi()

  • Pingback: Moe Beyond Anime: The Masked Alien Lover « Archetype()